Facebook Is Not Your Friend
Facebook is making you feel miserable.
I thought I was immune. I only went on Facebook to hear about the latest Trump scandals, hate-watch viral videos with titles like “You won’t believe what happens next,” and read interesting articles about technological breakthroughs that sound like they come from science-fiction novels. But recently I found myself spending more time than I’d like to admit skimming though the Facebook profiles of long forgotten friends and classmates from my childhood.
It was harmless at first. “I wonder what they’ve been up to,” I thought to myself. Very little, I discovered — at least in my eyes. Many had barely left the city they grew up in, most hadn’t pursue a college degree, and several were single parents. Scrolling through some of their posts, it seemed many of them had never really grew up.
Then it hit me. I was looking down on them, making myself feel superior by comparison, and I didn’t like the feeling. I closed my computer in shame. I caught myself in the act, but if you think back it’s likely you’ve done this as well.
“We’ve all skimmed through the social media accounts of exes, wondering if their lives have gotten better or worse since separating.”
Or perhaps you’ve experienced something else — that feeling of scrolling through your Facebook news feed and sensing that all of your friends seem to be leading lives much more interesting than your own.
We’ve all skimmed through the social media accounts of exes, wondering if their lives have gotten better or worse since separating. Everyone has that friend who never seems to be home, away in some foreign land feeding exotic animals. And if you’re part of the Millennial Generation like me, your current Facebook news feed probably consist of lots of photo announcements of weddings, babies, and house purchases.
It’s In Our Nature to Draw Social Comparisons
We all compare ourselves to other people as a way of determining our self-value. Psychologist Leon Festinger called this social comparison theory, stating that, “There exist, in the human organism, a drive to evaluate his opinions and his abilities.” A runner, for example, judges their running abilities by comparing their running times to others. A poet judges their writing based on the opinions of others.
“Social networks such as Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter take advantage our need to compare ourselves.”
Thomas A. Wills explored this theory further in his paper “Downward Comparison Principles in Social Psychology.” He explains, “The theory of downward comparison posits that persons experiencing negative affect can enhance their subjective well-being through comparison with a less fortunate other.” This becomes understandable if you imagine a cancer patient comparing themselves to a worse off cancer patient, consciously or unconsciously making themselves feel better in the process.
Note the words, “persons experiencing negative affect,” in Wills’ explanation. In the example above, the obvious negative affect being experienced is cancer. Wills points out that “Under ordinary conditions people dislike observing negative affect in others.” So if you find that you’re comparing yourself to worse off others and are feeling good in the process, it would be wise to investigate what underlying issues you might be experiencing.
On the other end of the spectrum are upward social comparisons, where one compares themselves to another they believe to be better off. This can be beneficial when used as inspiration. For example, if I want to travel more, seeing photos of my Facebook friends excursions can be motivating.
However, the effects of upward comparisons can be negative, particularly for those with a low self-esteem. If you perceive everyone around as being successful, and you don’t feel as though you have any way to reach their ranks, a upward comparison can prove depressive.
Social Networks Make Things Worse
Social networks such as Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter take advantage our need to compare ourselves. The desire to get the highest possible number of likes, followers, and retweets often dictates the content we share online. This results in the eventual creation of an idealized version of ourselves, where we give the impression that every moment of our lives is a Polaroid moment.
“You’re jealous of your friend’s Instagram account, but the filters, crops, and smiles hide things you can’t see.”
This online behavior creates two problems:
- People can no longer accurately judge themselves relative to others.
- Cognitive dissonance (psychological stress) arises in those presenting inaccurate versions of themselves online, causing one to essentially live an online life and an offline life.
Your single Facebook friends are jealous of the photos you share of gifts from your significant other not realizing it’s because that significant other is trying to make up for the -nth fight that week. Your jealous of your friend’s Instagram account, but the filters, crops, and smiles hide things you can’t see.
One study out of Tel Aviv University found that, “Facebook usage increases users’ engagement in social comparison and consequently decreases their happiness.” Think about it. If Facebook prioritizes posts from your friends that get the most likes, and what gets the most likes are generally positive life events, you’re going to be making upward comparisons all day.
Unplug from the Matrix
A Utah Valley University study on the impacts of using Facebook found that “those who have used Facebook longer agreed more that others were happier… and those spending more time on Facebook each week agreed more that others were happier and had better lives.” The situation is worse for Facebook friends who aren’t actually friends: “Those that included more people whom they did not personally know as their Facebook ‘friends’ agreed more that others had better lives.”
So what’s the solution?
- Spend less time on social networks.
- Minimize your social network interactions with people you don’t personally know.
- And for the best results, once you’ve cleared your social networks of strangers and loose acquaintances, spend more with your friends in person.
The study explains, “The more time people spent going out with their friends, the less they agreed that others have better lives and are happier.” This makes sense. The more you know a person in real life, the less you are fooled by their online persona.
If Facebook, Instagram, and other social networks have been leaving you with a sensation of depression, try at least one of these solutions out.
At the very least, next time you find yourself making downward social comparisons with the people you’ve liked, followed, and friended, pause. Remember that the person you’re comparing yourself to is fictitious.
Be mindful of the fictional character you’ve created as well. Don’t become a slave to the hearts and thumbs of approval.